Ep 81: The Kelly–Hopkinsville Encounter (Part 3)

Detail from Tim Bertelink's Artist Impression of the Kelly-Hopkinsville "goblin."  Image used under CC BY-SA 4.0 license.

"In and around the whole area, the house, the fields, that night, there was a weird feeling.  It was partly uneasiness, but not entirely.  Everyone had it.  There were men there that I'd call brave men, men I've been in dangerous situations with.  They felt it too.  They've told me so."
– Hopkinsville Police Chief, Russell Greenwell


Approximate location of the Sutton family farmhouse on Old Madisonville Road, in the unincorporated area of Kelly, about 8 miles north of Hopkinsville, KY


It's easy to dismiss the entire Kelly-Hopkinsville Encounter as the booze-fueled fantasy of a bunch of backward hicks who can't tell the difference between a goblin and an owl, or maybe you think it was an outrageous hoax perpetrated for cash.  But before you begin telling people what they saw, or make assumptions based on character or class, just remember: unless you were there, you weren't there.  These people didn't ask for this incident to happen to them, and they especially didn't ask for the notoriety or ridicule that followed.  What the authorities at the time believed, and what many skeptics agree on in hindsight, is that the Sutton and Taylor families were genuinely terrified of something real, and yet even the most seasoned paranormal researcher can't definitively say by what or by whom.  So maybe your educated reasoning doesn't allow for the possibility of otherworldly creatures?  Well, that's fine, it's a natural human desire to make sense of the impossibilities of our strange world with rationalizations that we can comfortably live with.  But as you do so, keep one more thing in mind: you can spend years or a whole lifetime developing and refining your rationale for disbelief, but it only takes one undeniable, paranormal experience to make you a believer.

Interested in Podcasting?  Come see Scott and Forrest at  Podcast Movement 2017  in Anaheim,   California    August 23 – 25, 2017    Use PROMO CODE " Legends50 " for a $50 Savings!

Interested in Podcasting?  Come see Scott and Forrest at Podcast Movement 2017 in Anaheim, California

August 23 – 25, 2017

Use PROMO CODE "Legends50" for a $50 Savings!


If you enjoy the subjects we cover on this show and love stories that take you down deep, dark "rabbit holes," check out Tanis, The Black Tapes, and Rabbits podcasts, from The Public Radio Alliance.  Subscribe in iTunes/Apple Podcasts or wherever you find wondrous and outstanding shows.


Reference Links:


Related Books:

Alien Legacy
By Geraldine Sutton Stith
The Kelly Green Men
By Geraldine Sutton Stith

Special Offers from our Special Sponsors:

  • The Great Courses Plus – Learn everything about anything with over 8000 lectures on almost any subject you can think of – and now for a limited time, get your first month's subscription for FREE and get your second month for only 99¢!  Check it out NOW at TheGreatCoursesPlus.com/LEGENDS
  • Policy Genius – One unfortunate accident or illness can devastate a family – that's why there's Life Insurance and Health Insurance, and now getting a policy quote has never been quicker or easier.  Go to PolicyGenius.com to save up to 40% just by comparing policies and it only takes 5 minutes.
  • Blue Apron – You will love how good it feels, and tastes, to create incredible home cooked meals with Blue Apron!  Go to blueapron.com/astonishing to check out this week’s menu and get your first THREE meals FREE, with FREE SHIPPING

The Dark Myths Collective  




Episode 81: The Kelly-Hopkinsville Incident, Part 3.  Produced by Scott Philbrook & Forrest Burgess; Audio Editing by Sarah Vorhees; Ryan McCullough Sound Design; Research Assistance by Tess Pfeifle and the astonishing League of Astonishing Researchers, a.k.a. The Astonishing Research Corps, or "A.R.C." for short. Copyright 2017 Astonishing Legends Productions, LLC. All Rights Reserved.