Ep 104: Resurrection Mary Part 3


“She didn’t put her thumb out or nothing like that.  She just looked at my cab….she was a looker. A blonde.  I didn’t have any ideas or like that; she was young enough to be my daughter.  Twenty-one tops.” – An anonymous Taxi driver who went by "Ralph," after encountering Mary in 1979 as told to Chicago Suburban Tribune columnist Bill Geist


LOCATION: Resurrection Catholic Cemetery & Mausoleums, in the town of Justice, IL, southwest of Chicago, IL.  From the Willowbrook Ballroom (recently burned down) all the way along Archer Avenue leading to the cemetery is where most of the sightings of "Resurrection Mary" have occurred.



How many reported sightings of a particular ghost would it take before you started to believe that perhaps people were indeed interacting with something supernatural?  Hundreds?  Over a thousand?  But you're looking for proof, you say.  Well, what would be convincing proof for you? What about mysterious, spectral handprints melted and scorched into bronze bars that have resisted repair and coverup?  Tonight in Part Three of our series, we examine the possibility that Mary may have left her indelible mark not only on the front gates of Resurrection Cemetery but also in the imaginations of Chicagoans ever since.  


Reference Links:


Related Books:

Weird Chicago (Haunted Illinois)
By Troy Taylor, Adam Selzer, Ken Melvoin-Berg
Just Kill Me
By Adam Selzer
Encyclopedia of Urban Legends
By Jan Harold Brunvand

Suggested Listening:

  • Listen to our guest appearance on the Chasing Earhart podcast from our friends Chris and Vanessa Williamson!  Come hear us ramble on about all things Amelia Earhart, including our favorite theories and the latest news & developments, like Dr. Richard Jantz's recent findings on bones found on the island of Nikumaroro!  Click here for Part One and of course, we weren't done clogging Chris' hard drives to the brim, so here's a Part Two Bonus Conversation!  Subscribe today!


  • In addition to a respectable oeuvre of books on fascinating historical and ghostly topics, our interview guest Adam Selzer has a terrific new podcast all about strange and forgotten tales of history, true crime and so much more on the way!  Go to his website: cemeterymixtape.com to listen and subscribe today!  


  • If you want to hear a great (and much more concise) take on the legend of Resurrection Mary, plus a large assortment of spooky tales about haunted places, creepy history, and forgotten folklore, all told in a narrative style by a real Ghost Tourguide, then you need to check out Mike Brown's Pleasing Terrors podcast!  Every two weeks, Mike will walk you through the dark shadows of reality and shine a light on the ghosts in the theater of your mind.  Go to Apple Podcasts or wherever you find outstanding shows and search for Pleasing Terrors, or click on, or copy n' paste this link into your web browser's locator: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/pleasing-terrors/id1141063625?mt=2  Your imagination will never be the same!

Special Offers from our Special Sponsors:


  • The Great Courses Plus – Learn about virtually anything, now with over 9000 lectures on almost any subject you can think of – from history and science to learning a new language, how to play an instrument or explore topics like food, the arts, travel, business, and self-improvement!  And now their app lets you listen to just the audio from the courses or watch the videos, just like a podcast!  Available for iOS and Android.  So head on over to TheGreatCoursesPlus.com/LEGENDS to start your special, limited time only, FREE ONE MONTH TRIAL with unlimited access today!


  • Blue Apron – Get professional chef-designed recipes delivered right to your door that are fun to make, and even more fun to eat!  These meals are restaurant quality, using fresh, inventive ingredients with simple step-by-step instructions that arrive with the flexibility your hectic schedule requires, and the flavor your taste buds demand!  And now, Astonishing Legends listeners can check out this week's menu and get $30 OFF your first order by going to BlueApron.com/astonishing.


  • The Confessionals Podcast – Listen to discussions with some of the most interesting authors and researchers in the fields of the Paranormal, UFOlogy, Cryptozoology, Conspiracies and more!  The Confessionals is a true-story based podcast where every Saturday night, host Tony Merkel interviews people about their projects or experiences with the strange and unexplained.  There are over 60 shows to binge on and guests have included L.A. Marzulli and Gary Wayne, Jim Wilhelmsen and John Edwards, owner and "alien slayer" of the Stardust Ranch in Arizona!  Look for The Confessionals on iTunes, Stitcher, Google Play, Alexa, and many other podcast players.  Or, go to their website: TheConfessionalsPodcast.com.  You can also support the show by going to Patreon.com/TheConfessionals and Patrons can listen to live interviews before they air and get access to live call-in shows, where they can connect with Tony the host and other special guests!

The Dark Myths Collective  




Episode 104: Resurrection Mary Part 3.  Produced by Scott Philbrook & Forrest Burgess; Audio Editing by Sarah Vorhees Wendel; Ryan McCullough Sound Design; Research Assistance by Tess Pfeifle and the astonishing League of Astonishing Researchers, a.k.a. The Astonishing Research Corps, or "A.R.C." for short. Copyright 2018 Astonishing Legends Productions, LLC. All Rights Reserved.